The cheapest unit price on a quote is often not the cheapest packaging. One supplier adds delivery, another charges for plates or a cutting die, a third quotes without VAT, and the quantities are never quite the same. This calculator puts the three quotes on the same footing. It strips or adds 15% VAT, spreads setup and delivery over the quantity and shows the landed cost per unit, the cheapest quote and the order size at which a higher setup with a lower unit price breaks even.
Compare like with like before you compare price
A quote is only comparable when the product is the same. For cartons that means the same board grade and flute, the same inside size, the same number of print colours and the same finish. A box quoted in a lighter board or a slightly smaller size will always look cheaper. For plastic and paper items, check the thickness or gsm, the material, the print area and whether the price includes cartons, labels or pallets. Ask each supplier to write the specification on the quote. If the supplier cannot state the board or film, you cannot judge the price.
Also confirm the tolerance on quantity. Printed work is often delivered 10% over or under, and you are billed for what arrives.
Setup costs, price breaks and the break-even quantity
Printed packaging carries costs that do not change with the quantity: plates or cylinders, a cutting die, a tooling charge or artwork. A supplier with a high setup and a low unit price wins on large orders, and one with no setup wins on small ones. The calculator finds the quantity where they meet. If the break-even is 2,300 units and you will order 5,000, the higher setup pays. If you will order 1,000, it does not.
Setup is usually paid once, so reorders only pay the unit price. Spread it over the reorders you expect in a year, not just the first order. Also read the price breaks: the unit price at 5,000 and at 10,000 may differ by 8% to 15%, and the minimum order quantity (MOQ) may force you above what you need. See the packaging price guide for rough ranges.
Delivery, minimum order values, VAT and payment terms
- Delivery. Ex works, free on road and delivered to your door are three different prices. A pallet to another province can add R900 to R3,500. Enter the delivery charge as quoted.
- Minimum order value. Many suppliers waive delivery above a set order value, often R1,500 to R5,000. Check what is left once the waiver applies.
- VAT. Quotes to businesses are often without VAT, while shop prices include 15%. Set the toggle for each quote so they compare fairly. If you are VAT registered you claim it back, so compare the figures excluding VAT.
- Payment terms. 30 days account against payment up front is worth about 1% to 2% a month in cash flow, and a deposit on custom work is normal.
The cost of buying too much
A bigger order lowers the unit price but ties up cash and floor space. Cartons take a lot of room, and stock that sits for a year can be crushed, damp or out of date if your design changes. Before you chase the last price break, price the extra storage and ask whether the supplier can split the order into scheduled deliveries at the same price.
Frequently asked questions
How do I compare quotes when the quantities are different?
Should I compare prices with or without VAT?
What counts as a setup cost?
Is the cheapest quote the best one?
More packaging tools
- Volumetric weightCourier volumetric and chargeable weight for one parcel or a whole shipmentTL-01
- Carton size and boardCarton volume, outside size, blank size, board area and weight for a slotted boxTL-02
- Cartons per palletCartons per layer and per pallet, load height, weight and pallets per containerTL-03
- Pallet wrap filmStretch film per pallet in metres, grams and rand, with rolls needed per monthTL-04
- Packaging tapeTape per box, boxes per roll, rolls per month and tape cost for I, L and H sealsTL-05
- Bubble wrapSheet size, metres off the roll, rolls needed and bubble wrap cost per itemTL-06
- Moving boxesHow many small, medium, large and wardrobe boxes, tape and paper for your moveTL-07
- Film thickness converterConvert micron, gauge, mil and mm, then film weight, m² per kg and grams per bagTL-09
- Corrugated board guideFlute chart, box styles and a selector that suggests the right board for your loadTL-10
- Plastic recycling codesWhat resin codes 1 to 7 mean: uses, heat, food contact and recycling in South AfricaTL-11
